I finally tried out the Colour Pop lipsticks. After wanting to test them out for a long time, there was a free shipping code, so I agonized over the colors to choose and placed my order. Here’s what I thought.
First, I was pretty excited to get a product with a theme, and some fancy packaging. Since I’m a frugal girlie, I wouldn’t ever drop serious bucks on my self for something as frivolous as lipstick. I love my drugstore stuff, and love that I can try out colors with low risk and sometimes NO RISK if you buy from a drugstore that allows returns.
Colour Pop had some Hello Kitty lip colors, and the packaging is to die for. From the minute you get your mailer, with this sparkly design, you feel like you spent a lot more than you did on the product.
Here’s my honest unpaid review of these colors!
I got 2 of the Hello Kitty colors. They were on sale for less than $5 a piece. I purchased Date Mate and Let’s Play
“Date Mate” is a matte bright pink color like my signature pink. I like it, but not in the matte. I think it looks too flat on me, and I need to add a little shimmer to the center of the lip. Here’s the shade in artificial and day light:
I suggest using a lip liner… here I did not. It helps to get the line nice and straight. (Here is it not.) On a side note… this lipstick broke pretty quickly. The cap is a snap on and I pulled it off and out flew the lipstick tube! It’s very pigmented, as are all the colors, so it required some scrubbing to get it off the bathroom sink and counter. Be careful around fabrics, I’m sure it would stain that very quickly!
The other Hello Kitty color is “Let’s Play.” It’s a pretty red with glitter flecks inside. Same sale, under $5.
Here you can see the gold glitter left behind when the color is removed.
The next color I tried was my least favorite. I thought the color was going to be way different.
Zipper was $6 and is a matte liquid lip color. Here is the color as shown on the website:
Here is it on my lips:
As you can see, the daylight photo is vastly different than the artificial light photo. But, I can’t seem to get the product to apply evenly on my lips at all. The above is a single coat. It went on streaky for me, and if you touch your lips together, it gets sticky and the coverage gets worse. I wish I had a matching lip liner, because this color is very easy to go outside the lines when you have only a doe foot applicator to work with. I noticed the color is kind of separating and pulling away from the tube….
Here I did a second coat to try to even out the color:
This color is definitely NOT user friendly, and do not apply this quickly in a crowded bathroom somewhere. A steady hand is a must, time to fix it, makeup remover on a cotton swab, etc. I’m not too crazy about how this feels on my lips either. When I smiled, the lip color cracked and my lip lines were clearly visible. Next time I might try to start in the center of the lip, so the color is not concentrated at the lip line, but this one is my least favorite. When wiping it off with a tissue the color rolls off, and none of the other liquid colors do this.
The next color is also a matte lip color called “More Better.” ($6)
This one, though it seems to be the same type of lip color as Zipper, is “more better” in the user friendly factor. I only require one coat, and the color seems to go on more evenly. I didn’t need to keep going over the streaks which causes even more uneven application. One coat and I was done. The formula seems less heavy to me, and less sticky. You can see how I wiped it off to show you how pigmented the color is.
I tried this one out for a long day of teaching dance. By about hour 6, the color had begun to feather around my lip line. I couldn’t just wipe it off, so I forged onward throughout the night, but it made me look like I had severe chapped lips and irritation.
The last liquid color I got was called “3-Way.” ($6)
It’s a metallic lip. I like this one the best for a dramatic night. I wore it performing aerial dance at a grand opening of a business. It stood up through the night. It’s easier to apply, feels as light as the “More Better” and is just as pigmented. It takes a few swipes to get the color even, much like metallic nail color takes a few swipes to get it opaque, but is build-able, unlike “Zipper.”
The third photo shows the gold glitter left behind when the color is wiped off.
Overall, I like the traditional lip stick colors more than the liquid lip colors. I just really feel like that Zipper color is a different formula altogether. It feels different going on and coming off the lips. I would try Color Pop again, but I’d be more inclined to try the traditional lip sticks that I can handle easier. The liquid lip colors are very much like any “stay proof” liquid color, except it feels like there should be a seal or a gloss provided to go on top of the pigment.
Primer: I did purchase the primer, and though the website doesn’t say anything about needing it, I believe the colors went on much more smoothly with the primer…..except that Zipper color 🙁
So that’s my beauty review of the Colour Pop lip sticks.
I’d love to hear if you have tried any of the different formulas or colors and if so what is your favorite?
Until next time beauties!